"The Progenitors were divine," Theron said.
Elara looked up from her notes. The diplomatic chamber smelled of fresh pine and old smoke—the Confederation built with whatever materials they could salvage. Stone walls from Progenitor ruins. Timber beams from the northern forests. Furniture cobbled together from a dozen different sources.
The Scavenger engineer sat across from her, his posture rigid, his tone clinical. He carried no scent of the road—no dust, no sweat, no horse leather. Just a faint antiseptic sharpness, like cleaned surgical instruments. Even his smell was optimized. Everything about Theron screamed precision. His uniform had no wrinkles. His movements were economical. Even the way he breathed seemed calculated.
Elara filed it away—she'd learned to read people the way scholars read texts, parsing meaning from posture and pauses. Theron's tells were buried deeper than most, but they existed. Everyone had tells. The trick was cataloging enough of them before the first real crisis.
The contrast with the makeshift chamber couldn't have been sharper. The Confederation built from necessity. The Scavengers built from design.
"Not metaphorically," Theron continued. "Literally. They ascended beyond biological limitation. Achieved technological transcendence. Left behind their works as gifts for humanity."
Elara set down her pen. Three years mediating between Valorheim survivors and Karthian refugees. Between blood mages and former crusaders. Between people who'd spent generations hating each other. Who'd killed each other's families. Who'd watched their homes burn.
She'd gotten good at finding common ground. At making enemies talk instead of fight. At identifying the soft spots in even the hardest ideological positions. Sometimes she worried that skill came at a cost—that each negotiation filed down another piece of her until she'd become as clinical as the people she mediated between. That one day she'd look in a mirror and see Theron's empty precision staring back.
Her brother's last letter sat folded in her vest pocket. Daren ran the frontier settlement at Thornfield—three days east, closest to Scavenger territory. He'd written about his daughter's first steps, about the new well they'd dug, about how the ash storms were getting worse. Simple things. Hopeful things. The kind of letter you wrote when you wanted someone to know you were still alive and still building. She'd read it four times already, tracing the ink with her thumb until the edges softened.
But the Scavengers were different.
"You worship them," Elara said carefully. She kept her tone neutral—not accusatory, just observational. The first rule of diplomacy: never make people defensive about their beliefs.
"We honor them. Preserve their legacy. Maintain their systems." Theron's tone didn't waver. His dark eyes remained fixed on hers, assessing. "The Progenitors created infrastructure to support civilization forever. Power generation. Resource distribution. Automated manufacturing. Humanity's role is stewardship. Maintenance. Continuing their work."
Elara picked up her water cup. The ceramic was cracked—repaired with resin that darkened the glaze. Everything in the Confederation bore scars. Everything was mended, patched, held together through sheer stubbornness.
She took a sip. Bought herself a moment to think. "And when you use their technology?" she asked carefully. "For weapons. For control. For expansion."
"We optimize their systems. The Progenitors intended humanity to thrive through organization. Through hierarchy. Through efficient application of resources." Theron studied her. His gaze moved over her face like he was cataloging details for later analysis. "Your Confederation uses Progenitor artifacts pragmatically. Without reverence. Without understanding. That's blasphemy."
The word hung in the air between them. Blasphemy. Not just wrong—spiritually wrong. Morally wrong. A violation of something sacred.
Elara kept her expression neutral. Years of practice holding her face still while people said things that made her want to scream. "We use what we find to survive. We don't worship it. We adapt it."
"You desecrate it." Theron's voice was still calm. But something hard entered his eyes—the first real emotion she'd seen from him. "The Progenitors left precise systems. Designed for specific functions. Your people scavenge components. Repurpose them. Connect systems incorrectly. That's not adaptation. That's vandalism."
Elara's fingers tightened on her cup. She forced them to relax. Deep breath. Don't take the bait. "That's survival," she said evenly. "We didn't have functioning infrastructure. We had ruins. Broken systems. Demonic corruption. We made things work however we could."
"Through ignorance and improvisation. Creating unstable hybrid systems that violate Progenitor design principles." Theron leaned forward slightly. The movement was precise, controlled. Everything he did was controlled. "The Scavenger Collective maintains original systems. Preserves intended functionality. We are the Progenitors' heirs. You are scavengers who misuse their gifts."
The sunlight streaming through the window caught dust motes in the air—or maybe ash. Hard to tell the difference some days. Beyond New Haven's walls, the Ashen Kingdoms stretched in every direction: grey-brown earth scarred by demonic corruption, dead forests reduced to skeletal trunks that clawed at the sky. On clear days you could see the ash drifts piling against the eastern ridgeline, slow grey waves that crept closer with each season. On bad days—storm days—the wind carried that ash into the city itself, coating everything in fine grit that tasted of sulfur and old death.
Today was a clear day. Outside, Elara could hear the sounds of New Haven—hammers on wood, voices calling, wagon wheels on cobblestones. The wind through the window brought the smell of sawdust and cook-fire smoke, of manure from the stables and the faint sweetness of the herb gardens tended behind the council building. Beneath it all lurked the constant undertone of the wastes—dry, mineral, faintly acrid. The smell of a world still healing from what the demons had done to it. The sound and scent of a civilization building itself from rubble, surrounded by a landscape that wanted to swallow it whole.
Her jaw tightened. The Confederation had fought for every scrap of technology. Died in demon-infested ruins to recover artifacts. Sacrificed everything to activate the Unmaking Engine that saved the world. Tomas Grenn and fifty others had given their lives to power that system. Elena had descended alone into the Deep Forge and sealed the Wurm Lords—primordial horrors that had nearly consumed the world—in an act of sacrifice that still haunted Cael. They had survived civil war, blood magic, and a madman named Kael who had burned Millfield to ash and tried to crown himself king. Kael now rotted in the deepest cell beneath New Haven, stripped of his blood magic, awaiting whatever judgment the Council deemed appropriate. The Confederation had paid for every victory in blood.
And this engineer called them blasphemous scavengers.
Elara set down her cup. The crack in the ceramic seemed to mock her—everything broken, everything barely held together. "The Progenitors," she said slowly, "sealed the Wurm Lords. Built the Deep Forge. Created the Unmaking Engine. We found those facilities. Activated those systems. Saved humanity from extermination. That seems like honoring their legacy."
Theron's expression didn't change. His face could have been carved from stone. "The corruption events. Demonic manifestations. We documented them. The Collective sealed our territories. Maintained quarantine. Allowed contamination to pass without risking our infrastructure."
"You hid," Elara said. The words came out sharper than she intended. She took a breath, modulated her tone. "While demons killed millions. While civilization collapsed. You sealed yourselves in and waited."
"We preserved. Maintained. Continued the Progenitors' work through crisis." Theron's tone remained clinical, but his posture shifted infinitesimally. A slight stiffening of his spine. "Your people fought. Died. Collapsed. Then scavenged ruins and claimed victory. Which approach better serves the Progenitor legacy?"
Elara's hands flattened on the table. The wood was rough under her palms—unfinished, unsanded. Everything in the Confederation was rough. Unfinished. Built by people too exhausted to polish.
She'd mediated between blood mages who'd sacrificed children and crusaders who'd burned entire villages. She'd found common ground between people who'd done unspeakable things. Who had legitimate grievances against each other. Who had every reason to keep fighting. She'd learned to see past the surface—to find the wounded child inside the war criminal, the grieving parent inside the zealot. Every monster was someone's child once. Every hatred had a wound beneath it that ached to be acknowledged.
But finding common ground required both sides to want it. Required both sides to see the other as human. As people worth negotiating with.
Theron looked at the Confederation like a mechanic looked at a broken machine. Something to be fixed. Or scrapped if repair wasn't cost-effective.
"Different approaches," she said finally. "Neither better nor worse. Different."
"Incorrect." Theron stood. Walked to the window. His boots made precise clicks on the stone floor. He looked down at New Haven—thirty thousand people spread across five districts, growing every month. "The Scavenger Collective thrived. Maintained population. Preserved knowledge. Continued technological development. The Confederation survived. Barely. Lost most of your population. Forgot most of your knowledge. Regressed technologically. One approach is objectively superior."
Elara rose. Joined him at the window. Below, a construction crew was raising a new building—timber frame, stone foundation. Workers calling to each other. Laughing. The sound of people who'd survived the impossible and refused to stop building. Beyond the construction, beyond the walls, the wasteland waited—cracked earth and ash-choked ravines stretching toward a horizon that shimmered with heat haze and particulate. A patrol was returning through the eastern gate, their cloaks grey with road dust, scarves pulled up against the grit that the wind carried off the dead plains. One of the horses limped. The wastes ate everything eventually—boots, axles, lungs, hope.
"Superior in preservation," Elara agreed. "Inferior in courage."
Theron turned. For the first time, his expression shifted. Slight narrowing of eyes. A tiny tightening around his mouth. "Courage without efficiency is waste. Your people died bravely. Died futilely. Died protecting a civilization that collapsed anyway. The Collective prioritized survival over glory. We endured. That's not cowardice. That's optimization."
"Optimization," Elara repeated. The word tasted cold in her mouth. Clinical. Empty of humanity. "Is that what you call abandoning people to demons?"
"We call it accepting losses we couldn't prevent." Theron moved back to the table. Each step deliberate, measured. "Your civilization fought demons with inferior technology. Inadequate knowledge. Doomed tactics. The Collective assessed probability of successful intervention. Determined the cost exceeded potential benefit. Sealed our territories. Preserved what could be preserved. That's not abandonment. That's triage."
Elara's nails dug into her palms. She forced her hands to relax. Three years of diplomatic training. Three years learning to sit across from people who'd ordered massacres and find the thread of reason hidden beneath the cruelty. To hold her face still while rage hammered at the backs of her teeth. To translate horror into leverage and grief into compromise.
But Theron made it hard. So hard.
"Triage," she said. The word tasted like ash. Like the ruins of Karthis. Like the memorial stones covering mass graves. "Millions died."
"Millions died regardless. Our intervention would have added Collective casualties without changing outcome. We prioritized preserving functional civilization over futile sacrifice." Theron sat. Folded his hands on the table—neat, precise, controlled. "Your people chose differently. Both civilizations survived. The Collective survived optimally. The Confederation survived traumatically. Which better serves humanity's future?"
The afternoon sun slanted through the window at a lower angle. Elara realized they'd been talking for hours. Hours of circling the same fundamental divide—philosophy versus pragmatism. Courage versus calculation. Fighting versus hiding.
She wanted to argue. Wanted to rage about courage, sacrifice, morality. About fighting instead of hiding. About choosing to stand even when the odds were impossible. About what it meant to be human instead of optimized.
But Theron wasn't wrong. Not entirely. The Scavengers had survived intact. Preserved knowledge. Maintained technology. They'd made the cold calculation and lived. Thrived, even.
The Confederation had fought. Lost almost everything. Barely survived. Rebuilt from ashes and trauma and desperation.
Both approaches had worked. Barely. At terrible cost.
And now they faced each other. Two humanities. Two philosophies. Two visions of survival.
Elara leaned forward, pressing her fingertips against the rough table. "We need to find common ground. Territory. Resources. Cooperation. Fighting each other helps no one."
"Agreed," Theron said. "The Collective proposes integration. Your settlements join our infrastructure. We provide technology, organization, protection. You provide resources, labor, acknowledgment of Progenitor reverence."
Elara's stomach tightened. Integration. A polite word for absorption. For the Confederation ceasing to exist as an independent entity. For everything they'd built—democracy, equality, choice—being dissolved into the Scavengers' hierarchical efficiency. She recognized the pattern. She'd seen it in Valorheim's treaties—generous language wrapped around a blade. The art of making surrender sound like partnership.
Thornfield. The name hit her like cold water. Daren's settlement sat directly in the path of Scavenger expansion—the first community they'd reach. Her niece, barely walking, would grow up calling some Scavenger overseer sir instead of learning to read in the schoolhouse Daren had built with his own hands. The abstract shattered into something sharp and specific. Integration didn't mean policy changes and organizational charts. It meant Daren kneeling. It meant his daughter raised to worship the Progenitors instead of choosing her own path. It meant every letter from Thornfield—every hopeful, stubborn, beautiful letter about wells and first steps and ash storms—replaced by efficiency reports.
"We're democratic," Elara said. "We won't submit to hierarchical control."
"Democracy without infrastructure is chaos. Your settlements barely coordinate. Your Council argues endlessly. Your military is scattered and disorganized." Theron's tone was matter-of-fact. Not insulting—just stating obvious truth. "The Collective offers optimization. Efficiency. Stability."
"At the cost of freedom."
"Freedom without resources is starvation. Freedom without security is death. Freedom without infrastructure is regression." Theron met her eyes. His gaze was direct, unwavering. "The Confederation built democracy on ruins. Noble. Idealistic. Unsustainable. The Collective offers sustainable civilization. The cost is hierarchical integration. That's not oppression. That's organization."
Elara's throat was dry. She reached for her water cup. The cracked ceramic was fragile in her hand—like everything the Confederation had built. Fragile. Makeshift. Held together by will and desperation.
But it was theirs. Built by their choices. Maintained by their sacrifices. Free.
"Organization that requires us to abandon everything we built. Everything we fought for. Everything we chose." Elara kept her voice level. "We won't do that. Can't do that. The Confederation exists because we rejected hierarchical control that enabled demonic corruption. We chose democracy specifically to prevent concentrated power."
"And created dispersed weakness," Theron countered. "Your Council can't make decisions. Your settlements compete for resources. Your leadership is exhausted. Democracy is ideal in stable conditions. You're in crisis. Crisis requires decisive leadership. Hierarchical authority. Optimized decision-making."
"You mean dictatorship."
"I mean competent governance." Theron stood. "The Collective will negotiate boundaries. Limited cooperation. But we will not tolerate Confederation expansion into surveyed Scavenger territory. We will not accept blasphemous misuse of Progenitor artifacts. We will not permit unstable democratic chaos to threaten our optimized systems."
Elara rose to meet him. Eye level. Refusing to be talked down to. "And if we don't agree to your terms?"
"Then the Collective will enforce territorial integrity. Through superior organization. Superior technology. Superior force." Theron moved toward the door. His hand rested on the handle—smooth, precise motion. "We prefer negotiation. But we will not allow primitives to threaten what we've preserved."
He left. The door closed with a soft click. Perfectly controlled, even in departure.
Elara stood in the empty chamber. Something nagged at the edge of her thoughts. The Scavengers had sealed their borders for a decade. Survived by refusing to engage with the outside world. Their nearest settlements lay three weeks' march to the east, beyond the Ashfall Barrens—where the air itself burned your throat and ash storms could strip skin from bone in minutes—and the dead rivers whose waters ran black with demonic taint, killing anything foolish enough to drink. And now, within weeks of the Progenitor structures activating, they'd covered that distance in days—appearing fully provisioned, fully armed, fully prepared with demands for integration. The timing was too perfect. Too calculated, even for calculators.
What had changed? What signal had reached through a decade of isolation and three hundred leagues of wasteland and convinced them to act now?
She pushed the question aside. The immediate crisis mattered more than its origins.
Sunlight painted golden squares on the rough stone floor. Dust motes drifted in the beams. Outside, New Haven continued its constant construction—the sound of a civilization refusing to stop growing.
Primitive. Blasphemous. Unstable. Chaotic.
The Scavengers viewed the Confederation as everything they'd fought to prevent. Inefficiency. Regression. Waste.
The Confederation viewed the Scavengers as everything they'd rejected. Hierarchy. Control. Cold calculation. Abandonment of those who couldn't keep up.
Common ground lay impossibly distant. A chasm too wide to bridge.
But Elara had spent three years finding impossible common ground. Between Valorheim and Karthia. Between blood mages and crusaders. Between people who'd killed each other's families. Between ideologies that seemed fundamentally incompatible.
She'd done it by finding the human beneath the ideology. The fear beneath the anger. The pain beneath the hatred. By making people see each other as people instead of enemies. That was her gift—the thing no one else in the Confederation could do. Not Cael with his authority, not Mira with her knives, not Aldric with his experience. Elara could sit across from a monster and find the person inside. Could absorb hatred like stone absorbed rain—letting it soak in without cracking.
If she could make mortal enemies cooperate, maybe she could make philosophical opposites coexist.
Maybe.
The alternative was war. And the Confederation couldn't win a war against superior technology, superior numbers, superior organization. The Scavengers' territory stretched across the entire eastern continent, their settlements connected by maintained roads and supply lines that dwarfed the Confederation's scattered villages. They would roll over New Haven like a tide. Absorb them. Optimize them. Make them disappear into efficient hierarchy.
Everything they'd built. Everything they'd sacrificed for. Everything Tomas and fifty others had died for.
Gone. Optimized. Integrated.
She could see it clearly now—Scavenger engineers walking Thornfield's dirt streets, cataloging every structure, every person, every resource. Assigning value. Reassigning people based on utility. Daren stripped of his elected position, his settlement reorganized into a production unit. His daughter placed in whatever educational track the hierarchy deemed optimal. No bedtime stories about the heroes who'd fought the demons. No choice about who she'd become. Just optimization. Elara's hand went to her vest pocket, pressing Daren's letter against her ribs like a talisman. She would not let that happen. Not to Thornfield. Not to any of them.
So Elara would find a way. Find leverage. Find compromise. Find the human beneath Theron's clinical efficiency. Find the doubt beneath the Scavengers' technological superiority.
Or die trying.
That seemed to be the Confederation way. Survive the impossible through desperate cleverness. Through stubborn refusal to quit. Through finding solutions everyone else said didn't exist.
The Scavengers had survived through optimization. Through calculation. Through preserving what they had and letting the rest burn.
The Confederation had survived through desperation. Through sacrifice. Through refusing to accept that some things were impossible.
Now they'd see which approach worked better when the two civilizations collided.
Elara gathered her notes. Papers covered in observations, cultural assessments, negotiation strategies. Three years of diplomatic experience. Three years of lessons about finding common ground.
She'd need every lesson. Every trick. Every insight.
Because this negotiation wasn't just about territory or resources. It was about the future. About what kind of civilization humanity would become. Optimized hierarchy or chaotic democracy. Preservation or innovation. Safety or freedom.
Elara headed for the door. She needed to brief Cael. Warn him that the Scavengers treated the Confederation as primitives to be absorbed or removed. Another crisis for a man who had barely recovered from the last one—from watching Elena die, from presiding over Kael's trial, from holding together a Confederation that kept finding new ways to nearly destroy itself. That negotiation would be harder than anything they'd faced before.
The diplomatic dance had begun. Now they'd see if they could avoid stepping into war.
The corridor smelled of damp stone and tallow candles—the mundane scents of a civilization that couldn't afford the Scavengers' chemical precision. Her hand touched the door handle—worn smooth by thousands of uses. Rough-cast metal, functional but unpolished. Everything the Confederation built bore those same marks. Functional. Unfinished. Scarred.
But free.
Elara hoped that would be enough. Hoped that freedom, even scarred and struggling, was worth fighting for. Worth preserving. Worth refusing to surrender for the promise of optimized stability.
Because if the Confederation surrendered that, surrendered choice and democracy and self-determination, then what had Tomas died for? What had all of them survived for?
She opened the door. Stepped into the corridor. The stone walls were cool under her fingertips as she steadied herself.
This was the Confederation's next war. Not against demons or civil conflict. Against absorption. Against optimization. Against a civilization that offered security at the cost of everything they'd built.
And Elara would fight it the only way she knew how—with words, with diplomacy, with the desperate cleverness that had become the Confederation's trademark.
One more impossible solution to find.
One more battle to survive.
The Confederation way.
Join the Discussion